Travel recovery: I was right on time, for the wrong reason
Looks back at International Travel Recovery? Not so fast..., from 2021.
In March 2021, I wrote that we were a little too optimistic about international travel. Recovery would start in the second half of 2022, I said, and run through 2024. And it hinged on one thing: the world agreeing on common rules for tests, vaccines and health passports.
Later that year, I left the travel industry.
I came back in May 2024. That was the year international air traffic passed its 2019 high, by half a percent.
So I got the date about right. I’m less sure I got anything else right. Here’s the scorecard.
Why I wrote it
Early 2021 was a strange time to work in travel. Nobody knew how the industry would move forward. Every country had its own quarantine, testing and vaccine rules. I was in product strategy for the Americas at Collinson, and people asked me all the time how we should make it easier to travel again.
So I wrote down my answer, for Business Travel Magazine in Mexico and for this site.
It made three bets. The first was the timing. The second was common rules, so a traveler wouldn’t face one set of tests in Lima and another in London. The third was business travelers. “For international travel to bounce back,” I wrote, “business travelers need to come back to the skies.”
The scorecard
The timing: right. The US stopped asking air travelers for a negative test on June 12, 2022. By 2024, international air traffic was 0.5% above 2019, according to IATA. UN Tourism counted 1.4 billion international arrivals that year, 99% of the pre-pandemic total.
The rules: wrong. No global standard ever arrived. The closest thing was the EU Digital COVID Certificate, which launched in July 2021 and which other countries joined over time. The US reopened that November with rules of its own. Then, country by country, the rules went away. Recovery didn’t come from governments agreeing on rules. It came from governments dropping them.
The business traveler: wrong. Leisure led. GBTA expected business travel spending to pass 2019 in 2024, but only in dollars. Adjusted for inflation, it was still behind, and so was the number of trips. International travel got back to 2019 without business travelers leading the way.
The forecasts I leaned on: too cautious. ALTA, the Latin American airline association, said the region would take four to six years. Air travel in Latin America and the Caribbean reached 451.6 million passengers in 2023, 3.9% more than in 2019. It took about three.
The product lens
In 2021, I looked at this the way my job asked me to. As a product problem.
Shortly before I wrote the post, I sat in on a webinar about digital health passports. At least five companies presented. Each one let you carry your test and vaccine records on your phone, and each one did it differently. From a product seat, that was the problem to solve. Five good products, no standard, and a traveler stuck in the middle.
I was right that the fragmentation was a problem. Nobody solved it. It went away when the rules did.
That’s an uncomfortable lesson for a product person. Some problems don’t get solved. They get deleted, by someone outside the room, for reasons that have nothing to do with how good the solutions were.
The commercial lens
The commercial question in my post was who pays. Who pays for the tests, the insurance and the vaccines. Whether airlines and hotels add surcharges.
I assumed the extra cost would slow people down, so I bet on the travelers whose companies paid. In the post, I wrote that leisure travelers would take one to four trips a year, “possibly less in a post-Covid19 world.”
Leisure travelers paid for themselves, and they kept going. UN Tourism puts the average spend per international arrival in 2024 at about $1,100, against about $1,000 before the pandemic. The tests went away. The higher cost of a trip didn’t, and people traveled anyway.
The operations lens
The operations questions took up the most space in my post. I listed five about testing alone. Should a country ask for a test at all? Before boarding, on arrival, or both? Molecular or antigen? Quarantine after a negative result, or not? Another test for a stay of less than three days?
Every answer meant a different process. Somebody at a check-in counter had to know the rules for every destination and check every document against them. In practice, that somebody was usually the airline.
I thought those questions needed common answers first. They never got them. They stopped needing them. One by one, the questions were retired instead of answered, and the counter went back to checking passports.
The traveler’s lens
In March 2022, I flew to Ecuador to see my dad.
Before the airline let me check in, I had to take a COVID test and upload the result. It was fine. A little friction, a few extra steps, and then I was on the plane. The US still required a negative test from everyone flying in, and would until June.
That trip is the data point my 2021 post didn’t count. I had spent a whole post on what would make travel easier. I never asked how much difficulty people would put up with to see someone they missed. The answer was a lot.
And that changed the politics. When that many people want to travel that badly, the answer stops being a better system for checking them. It becomes letting them go. People started calling it revenge travel. It did more for the recovery than any standard I asked for.
Here’s the part that stings. The evidence was in my own post. I quoted a Hilton study where 94% of people said they missed traveling. I linked to something I’d written about missing it myself. Then I wrote that leisure travelers weren’t the wild card.
Coming back
When I came back to Collinson in May 2024, I didn’t need a forecast to know travel was back. It showed in the number of visits Priority Pass was handling.
My own flights tell a smaller version of the story. In 2019, I took 77 flights, 41 of them international. So far this year, I’ve taken 17. But those 17 flights covered 55,060 miles, more than half of my 2019 distance in fewer than a quarter of the flights. My average flight is more than twice as long.
Part of that is my job, which covers the world now instead of the Americas. Part of it is the one thing my 2021 post got mostly right. I wrote that some companies would make their travel cuts permanent. Business travel came back in dollars, not in trips. Mine did too.
What I missed
I used to think the hard part of a forecast was the date. I got the date. What I missed was the reason, and the reason is the part you carry into the next forecast.
In 2021, I looked at international travel through every lens my job gave me. Product, commercial, operations. The one that would have gotten it right was the simplest: a traveler who misses someone. A year later, that traveler was me, holding a test result and getting on the plane anyway.
I first wrote about this in 2021, in a post called International Travel Recovery? Not so fast….